St. John’s Lutheran Church
Albany, New York
15 November 2026 + The Second Sunday of Advent
Proper 28 / Lectionary 33a
Matthew 25:14-30
The Rev. Josh Evans
Nothing says “A Thrill of Hope”
quite so much as
the outer darkness,
weeping,
and gnashing of teeth.
(Happy Second Sunday of Advent!)
“The kingdom of heaven,”
Jesus begins in last week’s parable,
speaking privately with his disciples
on the cusp of his own arrest, trial, and execution,
“will be like this…”
Ten young women –
five “foolish,” five “wise” –
a delayed bridegroom,
a midnight shout,
a scrambling for oil,
and a door slammed shut –
their expectations, distractions, and worries
cluttering the simplicity of the invitation:
Look… come… meet…
An invitation that comes without any expectations,
rousing us from sleep,
calling us simply to come and meet
the one who comes to meet us.
“Keep awake, therefore,
for you know neither the day nor the hour,”
Jesus concludes,
and continues,
almost as if not even taking a breath:
“For it is as if a man, going on a journey…”
There’s no doubt that this parable,
like the one immediately before it,
is challenging –
not exactly a thrill of hope.
Taken together, at face value,
these parables are troubling.
But, as we know by now,
parables are not so simple.
They are not pure allegories
or direct explanations
of the kingdom of heaven
or how God works.
For instance:
Any literal reading of this parable
that uncritically puts Jesus or God in the place of the master
immediately runs into issues
about the kind of God we believe in.
Characters in parables are not meant
to be one-for-one stand-ins
for people in real life,
like some kind of script.
Parables and their characters
are much more nuanced than that.
And no one example
could possibly encapsulate everything
there is to know about the kingdom of heaven.
Good parables are designed to make us think –
to help us work through difficult concepts
and come to a better understanding of them.
Which is why Jesus keeps offering
example after example –
and here is one more.
A man, going on a journey (to where exactly?),
entrusts his property to three slaves,
giving to one five talents,
another two,
and another one.
A single talent, by the way,
would have been approximately fifteen years’ wages
for the average day-laborer.
This isn’t exactly pocket change,
and here’s some guy handing out
one hundred twenty years’ worth of wages
like it’s nothing,
with almost certainly much more than that to spare.
Then he goes away,
notably without a single word of instruction
as to what the slaves should do with the talents.
There is an element of risk here,
both for the master
who entrusts his wealth to others –
What if they lose it all? –
and for those to whom the wealth is entrusted –
What do we do with it now?
Collectively, this is more money
than they’ll ever make in a lifetime –
there is enormous risk here!
No wonder the third slave,
with the single talent,
hangs onto what he has.
He’s afraid of losing it –
and so he saves it,
safeguards it.
That can’t be dismissed or overlooked
quite so easily –
and it’s worth lingering on.
Meanwhile,
the other two get to work “at once,”
trading and investing what they have been given.
And their risk-taking pays off:
five talents become ten,
two talents become four.
“Well done,”
they are commended.
“Enter into the joy of your master!”
But, in his fear,
the third digs a hole in the ground
and hides the talent.
“I knew that you were a harsh man,”
he admits,
and perhaps with a bit of risk-taking in his own way,
calls out his master’s questionable business practices,
“reaping where you did not sow
and gathering where you did not scatter,
so I was afraid…”
and he offers him back what is his.
And for that,
he is called “wicked,” “lazy,” “worthless,”
and thrown into “the outer darkness.”
Like a door slammed shut
and the bridegroom’s rejection,
it feels like a harsh word of judgment,
uncomfortable even –
which is where any allegory
for the kingdom of heaven
breaks down.
That doesn’t feel like the God I know
or the God that Jesus has been talking about all along.
To focus only on the harsh ending
misses the point.
The ending might be better thought of
as hyperbole –
a sort of exaggeration
designed to grab our attention.
This is a parable about
taking the risk of hope.
Jesus himself knows all too well
where his own risk-taking is leading him.
By now,
Jesus has predicted his own suffering and death three times,
and by the time these last three parables conclude
with next Sunday’s gospel,
Jesus will be arrested in the very next chapter.
But that doesn’t stop him.
For Jesus, no risk is too great –
not when it comes to sharing
the good news of the kingdom of heaven
and God’s love made real.
And so, he tells a parable
about what it looks like
to take extraordinary risks
for the sake of extraordinary joy
and the hope of a different way –
the way of the kingdom of heaven.
This is what it looks like to risk hope:
to take what has been entrusted to us,
not knowing exactly what will happen,
but trusting in the goodness
of a God who generously provides.
It’s tempting to fixate
on the third slave
and the weeping and gnashing of teeth,
to retreat to a place of fear
and scarcity.
Instead, this parable
invites us to recalibrate our focus –
to pay attention to the risk-taking of the first two slaves –
and to risk hope,
trusting in God’s abundance.
In Advent, we pray,
Come, Lord Jesus,
and we look with hope
to the coming reign of Christ
who has saved us,
who is saving us,
and who will save us.
Rooted in this hope,
and entrusted with gospel treasure,
we are invited
to take our part –
to give generously,
to proclaim boldly,
to serve selflessly.
To share with abandon
the love made known to us.
To take the risk of hope.